Tumblr Acquisition Deemed Automattic’s Biggest Failure
During a recent Town Hall session at WordCamp Canada 2025, Matt Mullenweg, CEO of Automattic, candidly addressed the company’s acquisition of Tumblr as his “biggest failure or missed opportunity.” According to reports, Mullenweg emphasized that while the platform hasn’t met expectations, Automattic hasn’t abandoned efforts to revitalize it.
Technical and Financial Hurdles Stall Migration
The report states that a key challenge has been migrating Tumblr’s backend to WordPress infrastructure, a move intended to streamline operations and reduce costs. However, with over 500 million blogs on the platform, the migration has been paused due to high expenses and Tumblr’s lack of profitability. Sources indicate that the platform continues to be subsidized by revenues from other Automattic products, prompting cost-cutting measures like layoffs and resource reallocation.
Strategic Shifts and Future Prospects
Mullenweg acknowledged that making Tumblr sustainable requires prioritizing other projects within the company’s portfolio. Analysts suggest that a successful migration could not only lower operational costs but also integrate Tumblr into the fediverse, enhancing its role in the open social web. The delay reflects broader industry developments where companies balance innovation with financial viability.
Broader Automattic Initiatives and AI Integration
Beyond Tumblr, Mullenweg discussed other ventures, including WordPress Playground and the expansion of Beeper, a universal messaging app. He highlighted that Beeper will soon support bridges to additional services, aligning with related innovations in digital communication. On artificial intelligence, Mullenweg remarked that AI is irreversible, with firms like OpenAI being “too big to fail.” He proposed tagging AI-generated images in the WordPress theme directory to improve search filtering, rather than banning such content.
Community Engagement and Legal Disputes
Addressing community concerns, Mullenweg focused on encouraging positive contributions through incentive systems, such as higher rankings in WordPress directories. He also commented on the legal dispute with WP Engine, referencing market trends in accountability. Mullenweg cited WordPressEngineTracker.com, which tracks sites switching hosts, as evidence of community action against what he termed “bad actions.” The site’s temporary takedown was described as an attempt to “muzzle free speech and transparency.”
Industry Context and Economic Pressures
The challenges at Tumblr occur amid wider economic pressures, as seen in recent technology sectors grappling with sustainability. Mullenweg’s reflections underscore the complexities of managing industry developments where acquisitions must align with long-term strategic goals. For further insights into Mullenweg’s discussion, a video of the Town Hall is available online.
This coverage is based on reported statements and industry analysis, and does not constitute financial advice or original investigation.
This article aggregates information from publicly available sources. All trademarks and copyrights belong to their respective owners.
Note: Featured image is for illustrative purposes only and does not represent any specific product, service, or entity mentioned in this article.
